The Obligation of Privilege

If you like this blog, send it to 3 (or more) of your friends and encourage them to sign up. Let’s keep the conversation going!

I am a person of privilege. I am well-educated, I know how to get the things I need, and I have the resources at my disposal to get them, usually. Privilege means having access and knowing you have it.

Being a person of privilege doesn’t keep people from getting sick – at least, not always – but it can sure help deal with the consequences of being ill.

For me, the obligation of privilege is to pay it forward: to do all I can to make sure that the benefits that I get are available to others in need, and to articulate my advantages in ways that make it clear that they reflect injustices that we as a society must address.

My topic this week is about privilege in health care. But I think you can see from the analysis below that privilege is a reality in all aspects of our lives, and needs to be addressed in all of them.

Privilege in the Politics of Health Care

Many Republicans are privileged. In a recent New York Times survey, people were asked whether it’s the government’s job to provide health care for the poor.  Seventy-one percent of the Republicans surveyed said no. But asked whether the government is responsible for provided health care for the elderly, 55% of Republicans said yes. Seems that Republicans can see themselves getting old – and entitled to government sponsored health care if they do. They just can’t see themselves as poor. 

I think most Republicans are, like me, people of privilege, On big difference between me and them is that they seem mostly — at least as far as this survey reveals – to think that their privilege doesn’t carry with it any obligations.

Stories of Privilege in Cancer

My story: When I was diagnosed with breast cancer, the word spread pretty fast among my community of friends. My friend Carol called to suggest I see a certain surgeon. I had already called that surgeon’s office, but he was booked for many weeks into the future. So, imagine my surprise when I got a call from my partner Susie saying that I had an appointment with that surgeon for six o’clock that very evening.

When I inquired later about how that appointment had miraculously appeared, I learned that Carol had a friend – Muffie — who was one of our city’s great movers and shakers. (Muffie tragically died of brain cancer last year at the age of 59). Muffie called the surgeon’s academic boss at the University of California San Francisco. She told UCSF emphatically that I needed to see the surgeon, and that they had better pay attention because I was the lawyer for the Speaker of the California Assembly, which had a lot to say about funding for the university.

I was, of course, deeply grateful for the effort that my friends had made on my behalf, at that same time that I was intensely aware that this is not the way the world should work. People who need to see doctors should be able to see them without the intervention of powerful friends.

I never forgot the kind of care and support I got when I had breast cancer, and used every opportunity given to me as I led Breast Cancer Action to articulate the need for everyone to have that kind of care.

Lance Armstrong’s Story: Everyone knows this story, I think. Lance Armstrong was diagnosed with late-stage testicular cancer. Through the miracle of modern medicine and the strength of his incredibly athletic body, he recovered from cancer, and went on to win the Tour de France.

But have you ever heard Lance say one word about all the access he had to the best care, thanks in no small part to who he is and the resources he had? I have always wondered why Armstrong has never used his considerable influence to advance the needs of all cancer patients to get the kind of care he got. Though I have seen lots of ads of Armstrong promoting drugs made by Bristol-Myers-Squibb, the company that made his very expensive cancer drugs.

Jerri Nielsen FitzGerald’s Story: Jerri Nielsen wasn’t as famous as Lance Armstrong, but she had her moment in the sun. She’s the doctor who, in 1999, stuck on the South Pole where she was working, did a biopsy on herself, and then had chemotherapy drugs airlifted to the South Pole. Later, she was airlifted out of the South Pole. Both the drug drop and the airlift out of the South Pole were enormously expensive. Dr. Nielsen was very grateful. She wrote a book about her experience, called “Ice Bound: A Doctor’s Incredible Battle for Survival at the South Pole.” (Later turned into a movie starring Susan Sarandon.) And, until her death from breast cancer at the early age of 57, she traveled the world as a motivational speaker.

But she never talk about the resources used to help her, or how we might allocate resources to make sure everyone has the care they needed.

A Story of Privilege in ALS

As readers of this blog know, I have ALS, an insidious, pernicious and unrelenting disease that is already making it hard for me to walk, and will one day put me in a wheelchair. In order to stay in our 3-story home of 36 years once I am unable to walk, we will have to install an elevator. One aspect of privilege is that we have the financial resources to cover the cost of this change. Another is more subtle, and that has to do with getting permission from the city planning authorities to make this addition.

Putting in an elevator means changes to the footprint of our house to accommodate the machine plus the room we will need for a caretaker. Changing the footprint of the house means we need permission to do something the zoning code says we can’t do. This is called a variance. In San Francisco, you have to apply to the city for a variance, and there is a somewhat involved process for getting your application heard and approved.

We were told by many people that this process could take months, and we don’t have months, given the progressive nature of my illness. But, as privileged people do, we have friends.  Some of our friends are people who understand the approval process and how to move it forward. So, thanks to these friends and the responsiveness of city employees to our situation, our application for a variance moved forward with what we hear is record speed.

We are, of course, deeply grateful for the help we are getting from all quarters as we work to stay in our home, but we are intensely aware that there must be others similarly situated who do not have the access we do to get what they need. We know we are no more deserving than these people, and that the system needs to pay attention to their needs when they arise.

So, once our construction is well underway, we will work with San Francisco city officials to make sure that the process for applying for a variance when disability is the cause is clear and understandable to everyone who needs it. That’s our obligation as people of privilege.

© Barbara A. Brenner 2011

This entry was posted in ALS Treatment, Illness and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to The Obligation of Privilege

  1. Amy Pett says:

    Fabulous post, Barbara. It is hard when we take advantage of our privilege in cases that are critical for us, like health care and your variance, and we know that others will not have these benefits. Bravo to you and others who recognize this and fight for access to these “privileges” for all. Neither good health care nor critically needed permission to make one’s home accessible for new handicaps should be “privileges.” They should be rights for all.
    Cheering you on every inch of the way,
    Amy

  2. Amy Allina says:

    I love the way you wove these stories together into a meditation on privilege. And I love that it’s inextricably personal and political. Seems very timely here in DC where the Republican House is fighting for devastating cuts to health care for poor people so that they can pay for the tax cuts they want to maintain for their wealthy and privileged supporters. Thanks, Barbara.

  3. mary Whitehead says:

    Barbara! I so love your position as :tiger at the gate” for ALL! I so believe in this position as well. And so how do we all revitalize the organizations with “their” agendas, which ultimately do NOT have a better picture for ALL as their goal? Sometimes you can’t participate in the work unless you adapt the point of view of the agenda-driven orgs…. so maybe you can “riff” on this for one of your posts? Hugs, Mary Whitehead

  4. Lisa Greenberg says:

    For me these themes echo throughout life: How much of all kinds of resources is each of us entitled to? How do we get what we need (and want) without contributing to others getting less? How do we act responsibly as people of privilege? Thank you for this post and for stimulating me to contemplate these issues. Thinking of you, Lisa

  5. Alice Philipson says:

    When I was stronger, younger, and healthier I used my Privlidge to help others. To have access to the things they needed & to make a difference in the Real World. I survived my cancers but lost most of my ability to wage war. And fight is one of the only things I am good at! I feel now as if I paid my privilege debt forward, and while I can and do act in small ways, the days of Big Action are behind me. The good is that it makes room for new heroes. And being a private citizen is OK. Not as exciting-but way less stressful! I’m glad Barbara fights on, we need her voice in struggle.

  6. abby abinanti says:

    Privilege….yes it should equate with responsibility….how come so few know that fact??? But you do and for that I am pleased. Because each person does make a difference….Elevator on….a

  7. Sandra Steingraber says:

    What a perfect essay for me to ponder right now. I’m in Buffalo, New York, preparing to talk to a community of people who live on the tailpipe end of some of the worst industrial pollution in North America and where diesel truck traffic is relentless. Asthma, and therefore disability, is endemic. My remarks will be translated into Spanish, so I’m advised to speak slowly. Tomorrow morning, after a predawn flight to D.C., I’ll be giving a Congressional briefing (on fracking) in the Rayburn building of the U.S. House of Reps. The privileged people in upstate NY say that, “if fracking comes, I’ll just move.” I wonder how privilege not only makes it impossible to imagine poverty–as you point out–but how it also disconnects and unroots us from the places where we live. We can imagine laying down a credit card and leaving. We can’t imagine staying here and fighting back, which is what the people in this community are doing. Does privilege lead to failure of imagination? Your essay suggests it might…but then there’s you, so full of imagined truths, Barbara, elevator and all. Love, Sandra

  8. Vicki Gabriner says:

    That your consciousness stays so strong & focused is a beacon of light . . .

  9. Teresa Friend says:

    Barb – I also think that it is very brave of you to talk about this now, instead of being somehow afraid, for example, that it will jeopardize your variance application. Good job!

  10. nora graham says:

    so well written Barbara.

    –except I wish all this were being written by someone I didn’t know–

    XXXnora

  11. Barbara Bryant says:

    Barbara, once again, you give so much of your heart, your wisdom, your political consciousness and your compassion in ways that remind, educate and motivate the rest of us. You are so right-on about the privileges many of us have – often including white privilege and wealth privilege – and the deep need for us to “pay it forward.” Do we “spend” it, sometimes consciously, sometimes unthinkingly, just to make our own lives more comfortable? Or do we, as you say, recognize it as the privilege that it is, and work to make those benefits and accesses the baseline for all? Indeed, you identify a need beyond just supporting social justice issues and progressive causes…. to self-reflect and get educated on the ways those social injustices and inequalities are reinforced every time we benefit from a privilege without acknowledging it as such and speaking out for a realigned world in which such “privileges” are afforded to all as basic human rights. As always, you are a dynamic and illuminating beacon for us all. With love…..

  12. Jody Schoger says:

    Barbara,
    Thank you for this wonderful post and your advocacy for hundreds, thousands of women with breast cancer. I’ve been directed to your work by friends of mine in the breast cancer community and am

    I wanted to add a gentle correction about Lance Armstrong. He speaks frequently about health care access and “the obligation of the cured.” The foundation that bears his name, the Lance Armstrong Foundation, recently opened a walk-in patient navigation center for neighborhood residents. He intentionally cited the foundation’s headquarters in Austin’s east side, a diverse, under-served area. He has a passionate understanding for both sides of the coin – growing up with a single working mother, and then using his resources, now, as a successful adult, to help others. His common denominator wasn’t as much privilege as it was grit.

    We all bring different gifts to the field. Yours, as the comments above so beautifully attest, are abundant. I thought you might want to know a bit more about what Lance has done, as well.

    Thank you,
    Jody Schoger

  13. Arlene Mayerson says:

    I would be happy to help with the issue you raise. The ADA requires accommodation and modification of policy and speeding up the variance process is a great example. Any one who has this issue can call DREDF (510 644 2555) and we will try to help.
    Thanks Barb

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>